Finance

That $895 Amex Fee is INSANE - But ONE New Perk Might Actually Justify It

Mike O'Connell

September 19, 20253 min read
That $895 Amex Fee is INSANE - But ONE New Perk Might Actually Justify It

American Express just dropped a bombshell on its most loyal customers. If you're a Platinum cardholder, you’ve likely seen the email that sent a collective gasp through the world of travel rewards: the annual fee is skyrocketing by $200 to a staggering $895.

For many, this move transforms a premium luxury into a serious financial question. With inflation already tightening its grip on household budgets, cardholders—from travel editors to finance experts—are now locked in a fierce debate over a single question: Is it finally time to cancel?

The New Math of Luxury

Let's break down the cold, hard numbers. At $895 a year, the card now costs more than many monthly car payments. To simply break even on this hefty investment, you now have to extract nearly $75 in value every single month. This isn't just about using a perk here and there; it's a constant pressure to maximize a system that seems increasingly designed to be complex. The value proposition has never been murkier, forcing even seasoned users to pull out their spreadsheets and re-evaluate if the prestige is worth the price.

A Coupon-Clipping Chore

Making matters worse is the convoluted system of credits that can feel more like a part-time job than a luxury benefit. The card offers a dizzying array of quarterly statement credits, from $100 for Resy to $75 for Lululemon. But here’s the catch: these perks are "use it or lose it." Miss the deadline, and that value vanishes forever. This turns the experience from effortless luxury into a stressful coupon-clipping chore, demanding constant tracking and planning just to avoid leaving money on the table.

The One Game-Changing Perk

However, amidst the sticker shock and frustrating complexity, Amex has thrown in one potentially massive game-changer: a huge boost to the hotel credit. Previously a modest $200 annually, the benefit has now tripled to an incredible $600. This perk alone could theoretically cover the entire $200 fee hike and then some. The only caveat is that it's split into two $300 credits, one for each half of the year. For a couple that travels frequently, this single enhancement could be the silver bullet that makes the $895 fee not just palatable, but a genuine bargain.

Ultimately, the decision to keep or cancel the Amex Platinum now hinges entirely on your lifestyle. The fee hike has sharply divided the card's user base into two camps. Are you a power traveler who can effortlessly cash in on the massive hotel credit, making the fee a worthwhile investment? Or are you a more casual user who will now be forced to chase expiring credits, turning a premium product into an expensive headache? As households everywhere weigh their options, the future of this iconic travel card hangs in the balance.